Best Pizza in Anchorage, Alaska

Anchorage’s best pizza — local picks, honest reviews

Best Pizza in Anchorage, Alaska: A Comprehensive Guide

Anchorage, Alaska, might be famous for its stunning wilderness and outdoor adventures, but it also boasts a surprisingly vibrant and diverse pizza scene. From gourmet pies with Alaskan twists to classic New York-style slices and authentic wood-fired Neapolitan creations, the Last Frontier’s largest city offers a delicious array of options to satisfy any pizza craving. Whether you’re a local seeking your next favorite or a visitor looking for a memorable meal, this guide will lead you to the best pizza Anchorage has to offer.

Moose’s Tooth Pub and Pizzeria

Undoubtedly the most famous pizzeria in Anchorage, Moose’s Tooth is a local institution and a must-visit for anyone craving exceptional pizza and craft beer. Known for its lively atmosphere and inventive flavor combinations, Moose’s Tooth consistently ranks among the top pizzerias in the nation. Expect a bustling environment, often with a wait, but the experience and the food are well worth it.

The interior is rustic yet modern, adorned with Alaskan art and memorabilia, creating a cozy and welcoming vibe despite the constant energy. Their commitment to quality ingredients, including house-made dough and sauces, shines through in every bite. Beyond pizza, their extensive beer list features a wide selection of their own Broken Tooth Brewing creations, making it a perfect spot for beer enthusiasts.

Known for: Inventive, gourmet pizzas and a vast selection of house-brewed craft beers.
Price range: $$ (Moderate)
Neighborhood: Midtown
Why locals love them: The unique and consistently delicious pizza creations, the vibrant pub atmosphere, and the excellent craft beer selection. It’s a true Anchorage icon.
Best dishes to order: The “Avalanche” (chicken, bacon, cream cheese, chives), “Denali” (pepperoni, green pepper, onion, black olive), and “Stone’s Throw” (pesto, sun-dried tomato, feta, artichoke hearts). Don’t forget to try a flight of their beers!

Bear Tooth Theatrepub

A sister establishment to Moose’s Tooth, Bear Tooth Theatrepub offers a slightly different, yet equally beloved, experience. Combining a movie theater with a full-service restaurant and bar, Bear Tooth allows patrons to enjoy delicious pizza and other entrees while watching a film on the big screen. It’s a more relaxed setting than Moose’s Tooth, perfect for a casual night out or a cozy date.

The menu features many of the same high-quality ingredients and creative pizza combinations found at Moose’s Tooth, alongside a broader selection of entrees, salads, and appetizers. Their commitment to craft beer also extends here, with a great selection of Broken Tooth Brewing beers on tap. The unique dinner-and-a-movie concept makes it a standout destination in Anchorage.

Known for: Pizza served in a comfortable movie theater setting, offering a unique dinner-and-a-movie experience.
Price range: $$ (Moderate)
Neighborhood: Spenard (near Midtown)
Why locals love them: The comfortable atmosphere, the ability to enjoy a great meal and a movie simultaneously, and the reliable quality of their food and beer.
Best dishes to order: “The Wolverine” (pepperoni, mushroom, black olive), “The Backcountry” (spinach, feta, sun-dried tomato), and their rotating daily specials. Pair it with a classic movie snack like popcorn!

Fat Ptarmigan

For those who appreciate the art of traditional Neapolitan-style pizza, Fat Ptarmigan in downtown Anchorage is an absolute must-try. Specializing in wood-fired pizzas cooked at extremely high temperatures, they achieve that perfect blistered crust with a soft, chewy interior and slight char that is characteristic of authentic Italian pizza. The aroma alone will transport you to the streets of Naples.

The restaurant boasts a chic, modern industrial design with exposed brick and warm lighting, creating an inviting and sophisticated atmosphere. Their focus is on fresh, high-quality ingredients, often imported directly from Italy, ensuring an authentic flavor profile. Beyond pizza, they offer excellent appetizers, salads, and a carefully curated wine list and craft cocktail menu, making it a great spot for a more upscale pizza experience.

Known for: Authentic Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas with a perfect char-kissed crust.
Price range: $$ (Moderate)
Neighborhood: Downtown
Why locals love them: The commitment to authentic Italian techniques and ingredients, the refined atmosphere, and the consistently delicious, perfectly cooked pizzas.
Best dishes to order: The classic “Margherita” (San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil), “Diavola” (spicy salami, fresh mozzarella), and “Prosciutto e Arugula.”

Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria

When you’re craving a classic, no-frills New York-style slice that you can fold and devour, Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria is the place to go. This long-standing Anchorage establishment has been serving up generous, hand-tossed pizzas for decades, earning a loyal following for its consistent quality and straightforward approach to pizza making. It’s the quintessential neighborhood pizzeria.

The atmosphere is casual and unpretentious, with a focus squarely on the food. You can grab a quick slice for lunch, order a whole pie for the family, or enjoy one of their hearty calzones or subs. Uncle Joe’s is known for its perfectly thin, chewy crust, robust tomato sauce, and generous toppings, delivering that authentic East Coast pizza experience right here in Alaska.

Known for: Authentic, large New York-style pizzas and slices.
Price range: $ (Cheap)
Neighborhood: Spenard/Midtown
Why locals love them: The consistent quality of their classic NY-style pizza, the affordability, the huge foldable slices, and the late-night hours.
Best dishes to order: A classic “Pepperoni Slice” or a full “White Pizza” (ricotta, mozzarella, garlic). Their “Meat Lovers” is also a hearty choice.

Pizza Man

A true Anchorage institution since 1974, Pizza Man is a beloved spot that offers a wide variety of pizzas alongside a full menu of Italian-American comfort food. Stepping into Pizza Man feels like a trip back in time, with its cozy, family-friendly decor and welcoming ambiance. It’s the kind of place where generations of Anchorage families have gathered for a casual meal.

Their pizzas feature a medium-thick crust, ample cheese, and a generous array of toppings, catering to all tastes. Beyond pizza, their menu includes pasta dishes, subs, salads, and appetizers, making it a versatile choice for any group. Pizza Man’s longevity is a testament to its consistent quality, friendly service, and enduring appeal to the local community.

Known for: A long-standing local institution offering a wide variety of pizzas and classic Italian-American dishes.
Price range: $$ (Moderate)
Neighborhood: Spenard
Why locals love them: The nostalgic, family-friendly atmosphere, the diverse menu beyond just pizza, and its status as a reliable local favorite for decades.
Best dishes to order: “The Alaskan” (reindeer sausage, mushrooms, black olives), “Super Combo” (pepperoni, salami, mushrooms, olives, peppers, onions), or their hearty lasagna.

Sicily’s Pizza

Located in South Anchorage, Sicily’s Pizza brings a taste of the Mediterranean island to Alaska with its focus on hearty, flavorful pizzas and Italian specialties. What sets Sicily’s apart is its dedication to generous portions and a unique, often thicker, crust that provides a satisfying base for a wealth of toppings. It’s a comforting, family-run establishment that prides itself on using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes.

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, embodying the spirit of a true neighborhood pizzeria. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Sicily’s offers a robust menu that includes not only a wide array of specialty pizzas but also delicious calzones, pasta dishes, and salads. Their commitment to quality and hearty meals has garnered them a strong and loyal local following.

Known for: Hearty Sicilian-style pizzas with a substantial, flavorful crust and generous toppings.
Price range: $$ (Moderate)
Neighborhood: South Anchorage
Why locals love them: The robust, satisfying pizzas, the generous portions, and the feeling of a welcoming, family-focused neighborhood eatery.
Best dishes to order: The “Sicilian Combo,” “Spinach & Feta Pizza,” or one of their massive, delicious calzones.

Bell’s Nursery & Pizza

For a truly unique and delightful pizza experience, Bell’s Nursery & Pizza in South Anchorage offers an unexpected but incredibly charming combination. Imagine enjoying a gourmet thin-crust pizza amidst the lush greenery of a garden nursery. This hidden gem provides a serene, almost whimsical setting, especially during the warmer months when outdoor seating is available among the plants.

Bell’s specializes in thin-crust pizzas made with fresh, often seasonal ingredients, some of which are grown right on site. Their approach is fresh, vibrant, and surprisingly sophisticated, proving that good pizza can come from the most unexpected places. It’s a perfect spot for a relaxed lunch or an early dinner, offering a peaceful escape from the everyday hustle.

Known for: A unique combination of a garden nursery and a pizzeria, offering fresh, thin-crust pizzas in a beautiful, green setting.
Price range: $$ (Moderate)
Neighborhood: South Anchorage (O’Malley)
Why locals love them: The incredibly unique and charming atmosphere, the surprisingly delicious and fresh pizzas, and the opportunity to dine amidst beautiful plants.
Best dishes to order: Their daily specials (which often feature seasonal produce), “Caprese Pizza” (fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil), or the “Prosciutto & Fig” when available.

Anchorage’s pizza scene offers a delightful journey for any food lover. While some spots, like Moose’s Tooth, can have significant wait times, especially on weekends, many places offer reservations or online ordering for convenience. For the most authentic experience, consider dining in to enjoy the unique ambiance each establishment offers. Whether you’re seeking gourmet innovation, classic comfort, or a truly unique setting, Anchorage has a pizza pie waiting for you.

← Back to AnchorageList.com